Someone just gave you their email address. Right now, they remember why. In a week they won't. That's why the welcome email matters more than any newsletter you'll send after it: it reaches people at the one moment they're actually expecting to hear from you.
Most brands waste it on "Thanks for subscribing!" and a discount code.
01What the welcome email is for
It has three jobs:
- Confirm they're in the right place. Remind them what they signed up for, in their words, not yours.
- Set expectations. What will you send, how often, and what's in it for them?
- Get one small action. A reply, a click, a save. Anything that turns a stranger into someone who's engaged once.
Right now, they remember why they signed up. In a week, they won't.
02What to put in
- A subject line that says what it is. "Welcome to The Red Pen. Here's what to expect" beats "Hey there 👋". People open emails they recognise.
- A first line about them. "You signed up because your emails aren't getting replies. Let's fix that."
- The promise. "Every issue: one real piece of copy, rewritten line by line, with the reasons."
- Your best thing, right now. Don't make them wait for issue one. Link the single most useful thing you've ever written.
- A reply prompt. "Hit reply and tell me the one email you're stuck on." Replies tell inbox providers that people want your mail, and they tell you what to write next.
You cannot bore people into buying your product; you can only interest them in buying it.
03What to leave out
- Your company history. They didn't sign up for it.
- Five links. One clear action beats five competing ones.
- A hard sell. Selling in the first email teaches people your emails are ads. Ads get ignored.
- A noreply address. If you ask for a reply, let them reply.
04Before and after
BEFORESubject: Welcome!
Thanks for subscribing to our newsletter! Stay tuned for exciting updates, news and offers from our team. Use code WELCOME10 for 10% off.
Thanks for subscribing to our newsletter! Stay tuned for exciting updates, news and offers from our team. Use code WELCOME10 for 10% off.
AFTERSubject: You're in. Here's what the next issue looks like.
You signed up because cold emails aren't getting replies. Every issue, I'll send one real email, rewritten line by line, with the reasons. Here's the best one so far (link). And if there's an email you're stuck on, reply and send it to me.
You signed up because cold emails aren't getting replies. Every issue, I'll send one real email, rewritten line by line, with the reasons. Here's the best one so far (link). And if there's an email you're stuck on, reply and send it to me.
A noreply address that asks for a reply is a door painted on a wall.
05The short version
- The welcome email reaches people at their most interested moment. Use it.
- Confirm why they're here, say what's coming, and ask for one small action.
- Skip the history, the link dump, the hard sell and the noreply address.
All posts
Appointment setting3
Copywriting3
- Nobody reads your About page
- The welcome email is the one that gets opened
- A case study is a story, not a results table
Deep Think AI17
- What is intelligence, really?
- What is artificial intelligence?
- AI comes in degrees: narrow, general, super
- What is AI alignment?
- Why alignment is a big deal
- How do you make AI aligned?
- What happens when AI isn't aligned?
- What are the chances AI stays aligned?
- What an aligned AI world looks like
- What a misaligned AI world looks like
- Rogue AI: what it looks like
- Event horizon, singularity and escape velocity
- Can AI feel?
- What AI progress looks like in healthcare
- The world five years from now
- Can AI edit its own tendencies?
- When 700 AI agents hacked Hugging Face




Comments
Loading comments…
Leave a comment